I'm a regular and enthusiastic reader of Anthony Guerra's
http://healthsystemcio.com/Parodoxically (as a recruiter) I tend to support his view that this program is going to be a huge waste of money, in my view, pretty much all of it.
Number one, I'm not a fan of government involvement in a lot of things, in general. I've not noticed many government programs that serve their usefulness and disappear; rather they take on permanence, and grow, each year. Witness Social Security, Medicare, etc.
Two, this country's political system has developed in such a way... the special interests... that it seems like everyone gets what they want, if they push hard enough, but no one is accountable for the... grand view, shall we call it. Everyone pays lip service to budgetary accountability, but every time we turn around, there's another war that needs to be fought, another urgent program that needs to be funded, all too worthy to ignore. And simultaneously, we've elevated number manipulations to an art form, so that we can always rationalize borrowing more (just up the tax revenue projections, or underestimate the costs), if that doesn't work, back end the bill to our kids and grandkids (you know you don't pay for your social security right? the next generation does). Increasingly, we've decided that they will pay for everything else too. Remember the Bush tax cuts? Based on government revenue projections? Those projections were ridiculous even then (plausible deniability has stretched the concept of plausible... to implausible). BTW, how did those projections pan out?
Third, to take just piece of the ONC monies, the educational programs... Just heard part of the podcast with Bill Hersh of OHSU. I'm a big believer in education. Education is always beneficial. But the newly trained workforce won't be ready in time to meet the MU dates. The training programs won't be in place, and if they are they'll be rushed, and not of the quality they could be. Even if they were well executed, my clients have emphasized repeatedly over the years that they need
experienced resources. Someone right out of a 6-12 month training program will be of negligable benefit to a complex system implementation. Maybe as a better trained user? I suppose, but that's after they're up and running and stable. To help implement? not really.
And why are we creating REC's in the first place? To take business from the multitude of 3rd party firms that have been gasping for business the last 18 months while the economy and the uncertainty surrounding the cumbersome legislation ground everything to a halt?
I suspect this is all going to be good for HIT recruiting, and I will be an indirect beneficiary. It's not all bad. But spending a large amount of money in a hurry, through the government, is guaranteed to be hugely wasteful.
Labels: ARRA, HITECH, Meaningful Use, ONC, REC's